loading
reading
writing
saving
searching

refresh the page.

craigslist

Collectibles For Sale in Buffalo, NY

  1. see also
  2. Vintage Anatomically Correct Ceramic Frogs
    $40
    Buffalo
  3. Vintage 1986 Pizza Hut Fred Flintstone and Wilma Glasses
    $15
    Buffalo
  4. Vintage 1980's Libby College Glasses
    $15
    Buffalo
  5. Metal Tip Tray ( Price Reduced )
    $5
    burbs
  6. Bills Framed Authenticated Jerseys
    $400
    North Amherst
  7. Buffalo Bills Highmark Stadium Farewell Season Commemorative Coin January 2026
    $100
    Buffalo
  8. 1988 Donruss Leal Baseball Box
    $30
    Albion NY
  9. 1994-95 Topps Premier Hockey Series 1 Pack
    $1
    Albion NY
  10. 1991 Topps Stadium Baseball Charter Member Set
    $20
    Albion NY
  11. Jack Daniels Tailgate Charcoal Football Grill
    $150
    Albion NY
  12. Buffalo Bills and Their Pets 2002 Wall Calendar MIP
    $10
    South of Batavia
  13. Bud Light Can Christmas Ornaments and Budweiser shirt Pin. 3-pack
    $2
    depew
  14. NEW GOLF BAG PHONE
    $28
    Erie
  15. Star Wars Episode 2 Pepsi complete Bottle Cap Collection and Stage
    $150
    LANCASTER
  16. Star Wars Saga Silver Anniversary (2002-2004) 5 Piece Set New in Star
    $50
    LANCASTER
  17. Star Wars HASLAB DELUXE Cantina Play Set In hand
    $650
    LANCASTER
  18. Star Wars Lava Reflection Duel at Mustafar Obi Wan & Darth Vader Actio
    $40
    LANCASTER
  19. Star Wars E-1 Droid MTT (Mobil Troop Transport) Pepsi Cooler Japan
    $400
    LANCASTER
  20. Maleficent Doll
    $85
    Cheektowaga
  21. Star Trek Soryteller Ornament set
    $80
    Cheektowaga
  22. Barbie by American Girl Doll
    $450
    Cheektowaga
  23. Signed Funko Pops Anime Disney Horror Authenticated
    $1
    Cheektowaga
  24. Collectible Star Wars figure
    $30
    Buffalo
  25. Star Wars figure
    $30
    Buffalo
  26. ANT MAN bobble head
    $20
    Buffalo
  27. Special 30th Anniversary Star Trek Vina as Orion Woman
    $15
    DEPEW
  28. TrueAir odor eliminator brand new set of (4)
    $15
    DEPEW
  29. NEW-MIKASA TULIP HEART DISH
    $10
  30. PIRATES OF CARIBBEAN SET
    $5
  31. NEW PIRATE FLAG 5ft.
    $5
  32. NEW PIRATE BANK
    $5
  33. COLLECTIBLE MADELINE PAINT SET - New
    $5
  34. OWL VOTIVE SET-NEW
    $5
  35. PIER 1 PLATE SET
    $10
  36. NEW- PIER ONE PLATE SET
    $10
  37. Bills 2022 AFC East Champions shirt -Large
    $25
    Lockport
  38. 2003 Iraq War Most Wanted Cards
    $10
    Collins
  39. Snoopy Wardrobe
    $10
    Buffalo
  40. Buffalo Bills White Frosted Pint Glasses
    $150
    Hamburg, NY
  41. Buffalo Sabres Chocolate Stanley Cup (1999) by Fowler's
    $150
    Hamburg, NY
  42. 12 Gates Brewing Tap Handle
    $40
    Buffalo
  43. Fisher Price Buffalo Bills Little People Shout! 2023-2024
    $25
    Buffalo
  44. Signed Buffalo Bills Mini-Helmets
    $40
    Buffalo
  45. 1972-2003 Winston Cub library 32 Books
    $0
    gowanda
  46. #3 Black Knight Tee Shirt
    $100
    Cuba
  47. ***Brand New Shawdow Box***
    $20
    North Tonawanda
  48. COIN - National Rifle Assoc.- M1903 Rifle Springfield Series 1.5” COIN
    $20
    Clarence
  49. Christmas tins
    $20
    Hamburg, NY
  50. Buffalo Sabres 1998 Mug
    $5
    Hamburg
  51. Sabres Stanley Cup keychain
    $23
    Hamburg, NY
  52. 3 Cream colored angels
    $5
    Hamburg
  53. Unique Mugs from London with scene
    $15
    Hamburg
  54. President Ford Pictures and Memorabilia
    $20
    Hamburg
  55. Russian Wood Burned Footed Jewelry Box
    $75
    Hamburg
  56. Russian Wood Burned Jewelry Box
    $50
    Hamburg
  57. Vintage Bohemia Glass Ashtray/Dish
    $30
    Hamburg
  58. Vintage NOS 1979 Scorpio Signs of the Zodiac Christmas Satin Ball
    $20
    Hamburg
  59. XXV Super Bowl Cup
    $10
    Hamburg
  60. Vintage Bird Clip Christmas Ornament
    $13
    Hamburg
  61. Brown Porcelain Creche with Miniature Pewter, Mary, Joseph and Jesus
    $40
    Hamburg
  62. NOS Ford and Mecury car fenders
    $250
  63. Goebel Hummel Ride Into Christmas 5th Annual Collector Plate West Germ
    $5
    Lockport
  64. Matchbox Premiere Collection Series 1
    $5
    Lockport
  65. South Park Collector's Pack Wind Ups
    $20
    Lockport
  66. ! Two ET Vintage Glasses New Never Used !
    $5
    Grand Island NY
  67. Mantua HO Conrail Set - Diesel, Caboose & Tanker,2 Freight Cars Lots O
    $125
  68. 2025 Proof Set With S mint Lincoln 10 coin set
    $200
    North Tonawanda
  69. Vintage hot wheels set
    $75
    Depew/Lancaster
  70. Swarovski Crystal Christmas Tree
    $21
    Depew/Lancaster
  71. Hot Wheels Crooze Editions
    $30
    Depew/Lancaster
  72. Batman Hot Wheels
    $18
    Depew/Lancaster
  73. Purrfect Cats Halloween Decor
    $13
    Depew/Lancaster
  74. Wooden 18 wheeler hand made various woods
    $45
    Depew/Lancaster
  75. Reduced Price -Pewter Arctic Fox on marble base
    $219
    Depew/Lancaster
  76. Reduced Price-Pewter wolf on a white marble base
    $219
    Depew/Lancaster
  77. Reduced Price-Pewter polar bears on marble base
    $219
    Depew/Lancaster
  78. Reduced Price-Pewter beaver on a white marble base
    $219
    Depew/Lancaster
  79. Purrfect Cats Halloween Decor
    $13
    Depew/Lancaster
  80. Betty Boop Mug & Pen
    $12
    Depew/Lancaster
  81. Barbie Celebration 2000
    $38
    Depew/Lancaster
  82. Betty Boop Slot Machine Vintage
    $55
    Depew/Lancaster
  83. Betty Boob Retired Picture Holder
    $70
    Depew/Lancaster
  84. Boyd's Catherine and Walter Q Fuzzburg
    $34
    Depew/Lancaster
  85. Boyd's Finicky Snottykat
    $15
    Depew/Lancaster
  86. Boyd's Huxley W Penworthy Plush
    $15
    Depew/Lancaster
  87. ** TEMPTATIONS 1.5 quart pitcher and 4 matching glasses. NEW in box.**
    $30
    Niagara Falls, NY
  88. 31” Darth Vader
    $90
    Clarence NY
  89. Dale Earnhardt 1:18 Stock car
    $90
    Clarence NY
  90. Banquet table covers
    $20
    Clarence NY
  91. Jeff Gordon #24 1:18 Stock car
    $65
    Clarence NY
  92. Molson Neon and Mirror
    $250
    Attica
  93. BUFFALO BILLS 2023, 2024 & 2025 Fisher-Price Little People Sets. MINT!
    $75
    Cheektowaga
  94. Hamilton Collection "Paws For A Cause" Collectible Figure LOT (6 NIB)
    $40
  95. Vintage Coca-Cola Sweatshirt Mens Large Red
    $25
    1037 Walden ave Buffalo, ny
  96. Beanie Babies
    $75
    North tonawanda
  97. Hockey Puck
    $20
    Lackawanna
  98. COMPLETE Harry Potter Funko Pops
    $5,000
    Franklinville
  99. Disney vinylmation figurines (prices in description)
    $1
    Lockport
  100. Disney Chronicles of Narnia book ends
    $80
    Lockport
  101. Funko Pop vinyl figurines (prices in description)
    $12
    Lockport
  102. Rolling Stones Tattoo You Wall Clock
    $50
    Sanborn
  103. Jim Kelly Art Print
    $125
    buffalo
  104. Jim Kelly Caricature
    $125
    buffalo
  105. Garth Brooks the first five years
    $30
    Alden
  106. 31 McD and Burger King Toys-New, Sealed-All $15
    $15
    West Seneca
  107. Vintage SNOWMAN Salt Pepper Shaker Set (Sakura)
    $10
    Ebenezer
  108. Sugar & Creamer Snowmen Set - Oneida
    $24
    Ebenezer
  109. New York Yankees Baseball with Stadium Seat Stand (RARE)
    $44
    Williamsville
  110. Vintage 1997 Energizer Bunny Pink Plush Drummer
    $9
    Williamsville
  111. (52) NEW YORK YANKEES Starting Lineups (every Yankee ever made 1988-20
    $400
    Clarence
  112. Best Friends Handpainted Ceramic Wall Hanging, Helen Goldminc Blue Sky
    $5
    Clarence
  113. * TEMPTATIONS Dinnerware 16 piece Set. NEW ~ no defects*
    $89
    Niagara Falls, NY
  114. ** TEMPTATIONS Cardinal & Poinsettia Dinnerware 16 pc.Set. NEW **
    $89
    Niagara Falls, NY
  115. Tiger-USA Folding Pocket Knife 3" blade. collectible item~ NEW in box
    $10
    NIAGARA FALLS
  116. 3 Road Signs NOS
    $180
    Lancaster
  117. Jumping Josh Allen - ONE OF A KIND Collectible!
    $225
    Buffalo
  118. GRADE IS HIGHER PLEASE READ :) !!! Factory Sealed Pokemon Emerald !!!
    $10,000
    Tonawanda
  119. Stamp collection 4 frames 3 folders marilyn monroe
    $50
    Tonawanda
  120. *NEW* EMPIRE STATE BUILDING KIT
    $35
    East Amherst
  121. "WILLIE MAYS" LIMITED EDITION SERIGRAPH by LEROY NEIMAN
    $9,500
    East Amherst
  122. *NEW* MICKEY & MINNIE WEDDING COFFEE MUG SET
    $22
    East Amherst
  123. Monopoly City of Buffalo First Edition - NEW sealed in plastic
    $90
    Blasdell
  124. DISNEY INCREDIBLES "EDNA MODE" SLANTED COFFEE MUG
    $18
    East Amherst
  125. RARE *NIB* BMW Z8 RADIO CONTROLLED CAR 1:14 SCALE
    $550
    East Amherst
  126. Brand New Shawdow Box
    $20
    North Tonawanda
  127. Masters Flag 2010
    $99
    N Tonawanda
  128. Saratoga Duffel Bag(2) (2016)($20 each)
    $20
    N Tonawanda
  129. Beer Steins-Schultz & Dooley
    $150
    N Tonawanda
  130. Saratoga Blanket (2022)
    $15
    N Tonawanda
  131. Saratoga Cooler Bag (2) 2015, $35 each
    $35
    N Tonawanda
  132. NEW BACHMANN ELECTRIC TRAIN SET
    $150
    COLDEN,NY
  133. Vintage LEFTON piggy bank
    $25
  134. NYSIR Accident Free Pin $10 each
    $10
    Clarence
  135. Vintage Nightmare on Elm Street Board game
    $175
  136. Diecast nascar collection
    $200
    Grand Island
  137. Diecast cars nascar collection
    $150
    Grand Island
  138. Vintage W.R.R.S. Co. Type 1880 Railroad Electric Switch Lamp
    $275
    Williamsville
  139. Lehmann-Gross-Bahn (LGB) G-Guage Train Collection
    $3,500
    Williamsville
  140. ***Brand New Shawdow Box***
    $20
    North Tonawanda
  141. Porcelain doll
    $20
    Lancaster
  142. Trump Bobble Head
    $20
  143. Cup and Saucer
    $20
  144. New In Package
    $15
  145. COLLECTIBLE NEW WEBKINZ BENGAL TIGER
    $10
  146. NEW SANTA COOKIE JAR
    $25
  147. NEW SINGLE SERVING BLACK TEA POT
    $5
  148. GOVERNORS MANSIONS BOOK- NEW
    $3
  149. NEW-ROOSTER PLACEMAT SET
    $10
  150. NEW COLLECTABLE SILK TIE
    $5
  151. QUILT PIECED PLACEMAT SET
    $5
  152. COLLECTIBLE DERBY COINS
    $5
  153. 50’s TABLE TOPPER
    $5
  154. RARE EXCLUSIVE DESIGN-ATLANTA LOGO
    $10
  155. HANDMADE GOURD BIRDHOUSE
    $5
  156. COLLECTIBLE RETIRED LLADRO
    $50
  157. Star Trek Pez 25th Anniversary
    $0
  158. Bobble Head
    $20
  159. Uncirculated Dual Mint $1 Sacagawea Golden Collection
    $500
    Medina
  160. Santa’s Workbench Valleyview Manor
    $29
  161. Santa’s Workbench Gazebo
    $29
  162. Santa’s Workbench Cornerstone Café
    $29
  163. 1996 Budweiser 19" Lighted Wall Clock (New)
    $75
    Cheektowaga
  164. 2003 True Value 1:25 Scale Graham Brothers Delivery Truck (MIB)
    $25
    Cheektowaga
  165. 1999 Coca Cola Collector Monopoly Board Game (New Sealed)
    $40
    Cheektowaga
  166. Hot Wheels 1997 Series Car Collection January-December (New)
    $160
    Cheektowaga
  167. 2000 Hasbro GI Joe 12" Scramble Pilot NIB Sealed
    $50
    Cheektowaga
  168. 1990 Hot Wheels Billionth Car Collector Set of 4 NIB
    $100
    Cheektowaga
  169. 20" x 18" Labatt's Big Deal Brewing Metal Sign (New)
    $30
    Cheektowaga
  170. 1995 Coca Cola Collectors 6oz. Beverage Set
    $20
    Cheektowaga
  171. The Drinking Chess Set with 30 Shot Glasses NEW
    $10
    Buffalo
  172. NEW INSPIRATIONAL MUG
    $5
  173. NEW- GLASS BEER STEIN- XL
    $3
  174. COKE 75th ANNIVERSARY GLASS SET
    $15
  175. Vintage 1999 WWF “Tude Time” Clock – New in Box, Tested & Working
    $70
    Hamburg / Boston
  176. WWF Maximum Sweat Shawn Michaels Figure – New in Package
    $15
    Hamburg / Boston
  177. Buffalo Bills novelty golf club
    $30
    Amherst
  178. CASE Clasp, Bulldog, Zipper knives
    $1,785
    Niagara Falls
  179. Crown XR Red box.
    $1,100
  180. BOOK Coin Collecting For Kids (No coins) NEW
    $15
    Clarence
  181. Santa’s Workbench Church of the Devoted Shepherd
    $29
  182. Rick and Morty Galaxy s22 cell phone case
    $15
    Elmwood
  183. Santa’s Workbench Hearthstone Bakery
    $29
  184. SET NEW BILLS MUGS $10.
    $10
    Buffalo
  185. Disney FROZEN Collectibles
    $165
    Depew
  186. Baby Ruth baseballs
    $15
    hamburg
  187. Safe Driver Pins - years 1-6 - $5 each
    $5
    Clarence
  188. Pez Dispensers (3)
    $10
    Cheektowaga
  189. Official signed NFL football by Rob Gronkowski number 87
    $250
    west seneca
  190. 16X24 Panini Instant Impressions Keon Coleman Rookie Handrpint Autograph /10
    $1
    East Amherst
  191. AGWAY 1:64 Hauler
    $50
    Elma
  192. Box of Flutie Flakes
    $20
    Williamsville
  193. 1974 VINTAGE DECANTER MERCEDES BENZ(SEALED IN BOX )
    $45
    CLARENCE
  194. New Vintage Hall 6-Cup Teapot
    $35
    Williamsville
  195. Autographed Kyle Okposo
    $30
    Lockport
  196. Will Clark SLU, 1990
    $1
    Amherst
  197. Carlos Baerga SLU
    $1
    Amherst
  198. Will Clark SLU, 1991
    $1
    Amherst
  199. Ken Griffey Jr SLU, 1991
    $3
    Amherst
  200. Jose Canseco SLU, 1988
    $1
    Amherst
  201. Jose Canseco SLU, 1991
    $1
    Amherst
  202. Brian McRae
    $1
    Amherst
  203. Frank Thomas Headline Collection
    $5
    Amherst
  204. SLU Headline Collection Collection
    $20
    Amherst
  205. Miller Beer mug
    $5
    Amherst
  206. Ken Griffey Jr SLU, 1993
    $3
    Amherst
  207. Kevin Maas SLU, 1991
    $1
    Amherst
  208. Mark McGwire SLU, 1991
    $1
    Amherst
  209. David Justice SLU
    $1
    Amherst
  210. Bo Jackson SLU, 1991
    $2
    Amherst
  211. Will Clark SLU 1993
    $1
    Amherst
  212. Juan Gonzalez SLU
    $1
    Amherst
  213. Kevin Maas SLU, 1992
    $1
    Amherst
  214. Gregg Jefferies Statue
    $2
    Amherst
  215. Will Clark SLU 1988
    $1
    Amherst
  216. Kenner Starting Lineup Collection
    $190
    Amherst
  217. Mark McGwire SLU, 1993
    $1
    Amherst
  218. Jose Canseco SLU, 1990
    $1
    Amherst
  219. Score 1991 Baseball Rookie Cards
    $1
    Amherst
  220. Ken Griffey Jr SLU, 1992
    $3
    Amherst
  221. Fleer 1990 Premiere Edition Football Cards
    $40
    Amherst
  222. Ken Griffey Jr. Stadium Star
    $8
    Amherst
  223. Will Clark SLU 1989
    $1
    Amherst
  224. Gregg Jefferies SLU
    $1
    Amherst
  225. Jim Abbott SLU
    $1
    Amherst
  226. Will Clark SLU, 1992
    $1
    Amherst
  227. Derrick Coleman SLU Figure
    $1
    Amherst
  228. Kevin Mitchell SLU, 1990
    $1
    Amherst
  229. Ken Griffey Jr SLU 1990
    $3
    Amherst
  230. Bo Jackson SLU 1992
    $2
    Amherst
  231. Classic Baseball Card Game
    $1
    Amherst
  232. Jose Canseco SLU, 1989
    $1
    Amherst
  233. Tom Seaver SLU
    $3
    Amherst
  234. Frank Thomas 1992 SLU
    $2
    Amherst
  235. Bo Jackson SLU, 1991
    $2
    Amherst
  236. Bo Jackson SLU 1992
    $2
    Amherst
  237. Todd Van Poppel SLU
    $1
    Amherst
  238. Mark McGwire SLU 1989
    $1
    Amherst
  239. Frank Thomas 1992 SLU
    $2
    Amherst
  240. Frank Thomas Stadium Star
    $7
    Amherst
  241. Jose Canseco SLU, 1993
    $1
    Amherst
  242. Ken Griffey Jr Headline Collection
    $6
    Amherst
  243. Ken Griffey Jr SLU, 1991
    $3
    Amherst
  244. Mark McGwire SLU, 1990
    $1
    Amherst
  245. Ken Griffey Jr SLU, 1992
    $3
    Amherst
  246. Kevin Mitchell SLU, 1991
    $1
    Amherst
  247. Ben McDonald SLU
    $1
    Amherst
  248. Frank Thomas 1993 SLU
    $2
    Amherst
  249. Cal Ripken Jr. Bobblehead
    $12
    Amherst
  250. Nolan Ryan Headline Collection
    $7
    Amherst
  251. Classic Basketball Cards 1991
    $1
    Amherst
  252. Jose Canseco SLU, 1992
    $1
    Amherst
  253. Nolan Ryan Stadium Star
    $8
    Amherst
  254. FISHING - Yellow Freight Mepps spinner fishing lure NEW collectible
    $20
    Clarence
  255. PINNACLE 98 CARDS IN A CAN
    $5
    Elma
  256. 1984 Budweiser Clydesdale Pilsner Glasses Set of 4
    $25
    Cheektowaga
  257. 1992 ELVIS PRESLEY COMPLETE 12 PLATE HIT PARADE COLLECTION w/ COAs
    $85
    Amherst
  258. US proof sets. Coins
    $100
  259. Cherished Teddies 5 Year Commemorative Anniversary Figurine 1996 Lt.Ed
    $20
    Clarence
  260. Eeyore PEZ dispenser, collectible - NEW in package
    $15
    Clarence
  261. Star Trek
    $1
  262. Battlestar galactica
    $1
    Buffalo
  263. Zippo NEW Camel cigarette lighter Collectible
    $75
    Clarence
  264. Pepsi Red Zeon Light
    $75
    Buffalo
  265. 1994 BARBIE QUEEN Of HEARTS Doll BOB MACKIE Designer Series MINT NRFB
    $95
    BUFFALO, NY
  266. 1995 BARBIE SUN GODDESS Doll BOB MACKIE Designer Series MINT NRFB
    $95
    BUFFALO, NY
  267. 1996 BARBIE MOON GODDESS Doll BOB MACKIE Designer Series MINT NRFB
    $95
    BUFFALO, NY
  268. Pokémon tags number 39 Jigglypuff
    $20
    Hamburg
  269. Yoda Star Wars
    $40
    Hamburg
  270. Philipps Bros. supply shop clock
    $20
    Hamburg
  271. Yoda Star Wars
    $50
    Hamburg
  272. MANDALORIAN THE CHILD Hallmark Decoupage Ornament TARGET EXCLUSIVE
    $12
    BUFFALO, NY
  273. Disney Mickey Mouse, vintage watch (new), & Donald Duck doll
    $30
    Clarence
  274. Mary Poppins spoons
    $20
    ORCHARD PARK
  275. JRR Tolkien 1978 Calendar
    $50
    ORCHARD PARK
  276. Christmas Hallmark Ornament "Sister" with kitty in basket
    $10
    Clarence
  277. Boyd's Bears Holiday Patriotic Star Spangled Nick Santa, Lights
    $55
    Clarence
  278. Vintage Crystal Wine Glasses 6 PCs.
    $30
    Buffalo
  279. Lenox Snowman's Snowflake Surprise Christmas Ornament 3.25"
    $15
    Tonawanda
  280. Star Wars Landspeeder POTF 1995
    $25
    Tonawanda
  281. CARTOONIST CONSTITUTION- A Cartoon Celebration of America PUZZLE
    $20
    Friendship
  282. 122 First Day Covers in Album 1970’s
    $122
    Clarence
  283. Ty Beanie Baby Bearon Bear (100 years of flight)
    $15
    Clarence
  284. Audrey Hepburn black daytime ensemble breakfast at tiffany' Barbie
    $60
    Orchard Park
  285. Nascar Small Mini Racing Helments (new)
    $10
    Buffalo
  286. Lou Gehrig unused collectible sheet of 50 Stamps 1989
    $40
    Clarence
  287. Braniff airline lighters
    $75
    Blasdelll
  288. Canada's 10 Provincial Coats of Arms, Vintage Coasters
    $8
    Clarence
  289. Christmas Ceramic Ornament "Christmas Morning Stocking"
    $3
    Clarence
  290. Bendable Fisherman “Wade” Bendos - NEW
    $8
    Clarence
  291. Architecture corner block stamps unused issued 1982
    $3
    Clarence
  292. Classic American Dolls U.S. stamp sheet 32 cents
    $15
    Clarence
  293. Jackie Robinson corner block postage stamps unused issued 1982
    $4
    Clarence
  294. Safe Driver Award Pin - National Safety Council
    $20
    Clarence
  295. 1999 STAR WARS Phantom Menace CUP TOPPERS - KFC Pizza Hut Taco Bell
    $15
    BUFFALO, NY
  296. Boston Tea Party corner block postage stamps unused issued 1973
    $2
    Clarence
  297. Batman dark knight cowl replica
    $80
    Lockport
  298. Christmas Hallmark Ornament "Treetop Choir" Bluebirds
    $10
    Clarence
  299. Josh Allen duke football
    $600
    Hamburg
  300. Harley Davidson Annuals
    $30
    Williamsville